Ask a walker to name two Lake District mountains and the answer is nearly always the same: Scafell Pike, because it is the highest ground in England, and Helvellyn, because of Striding Edge. Both are climbed by enormous numbers of people every year, and both are still, on the wrong day, entirely capable of catching out anyone who treats them as a stroll. We have walked each of them in every season, and what follows is the version of the classic days we would recommend to a friend: the routes that give the mountain its due, the places where the ground changes character, and the decisions that matter most.
Scafell Pike: the highest point, and the least obvious
Scafell Pike stands at 978 metres, a few metres higher than its neighbour Scafell at 964 metres, and the two are separated by the narrow col of Mickledore. From most of the valleys the Pike hides behind other fells, which is why so many first-time visitors are surprised by how far it is from anywhere. The summit itself is a broad dome of shattered boulders with a large circular cairn, and in mist it is one of the hardest summits in the Lakes to leave in the right direction. Cairns radiate in several directions, and several of them lead onto ground you do not want to be on.
There are three classic approaches. From Wasdale Head, the direct path is the shortest, roughly four and a half kilometres each way with about 900 metres of ascent, and most parties allow three hours up and two down. It is a steep, relentless staircase of pitched stone, and it delivers you to the summit with none of the surrounding scenery to soften it. From Borrowdale, the Corridor Route from Seathwaite passes Styhead Tarn and then traverses under the crags of Great End and Broad Crag before the final climb; it is a longer day, around fourteen to sixteen kilometres in total, and comfortably the finest way up. From Great Langdale, the walk over Esk Hause is longer again and gives the least crowded start.
Reading the summit plateau
Whichever route you take, the last 200 metres of ascent cross the boulder field. There is no soil here, only rock, and in wet weather the lichen-covered blocks are slippery enough to send an ankle sideways. On the descent, the standard advice bears repeating: from the summit cairn, identify the correct line before you set off, not after. Mickledore lies to the south-west, and beyond it the notorious Broad Stand, a rock step that is a climb, not a walk, and the site of many accidents. Lord’s Rake and the West Wall Traverse, on the Scafell side, are equally unsuitable for walkers. If you cannot see the Corridor Route or the Wasdale path clearly, the safe habit is to take a compass bearing from the cairn and follow it, not to follow the nearest set of footprints.
Helvellyn and the eastern coves
Helvellyn, at 950 metres, is the third highest mountain in England and the most approachable of the big three. Its western side above Thirlmere is a long grass slope, and the path from Wythburn or Swirls is a straightforward pull up with nothing to trouble anyone in good weather. The east side is a different mountain. Glaciers scooped two great coves out of the ridge, leaving Red Tarn cupped between two narrow aretes: Striding Edge to the south and Swirral Edge to the north, with the pointed subsidiary summit of Catstye Cam at 890 metres beyond.
The classic day starts in Glenridding or Patterdale, climbs to the wall gap known as Hole-in-the-Wall, and takes the edges as a horseshoe: up Striding Edge, across the summit plateau, down Swirral Edge, and back past Red Tarn. It is around thirteen kilometres with roughly 900 metres of ascent, and five to seven hours is realistic for most parties, longer if the ridge is busy.
Striding Edge, step by step
Striding Edge is a grade one scramble, which in summer means hands are used for balance rather than for pulling. The crest is narrow and blocky for about a kilometre, with a path that dodges left and right just below the top. Purists stay on the crest throughout; the path is easier and only slightly less exposed. The technical crux comes near the Helvellyn end, where a short rock step, the Chimney, has to be down-climbed onto a small col. It is only a few metres, but it is polished and it faces the drop, and most falls on the ridge happen here or on the loose ground immediately after it. Above the col a steep, eroded scramble of about 100 metres leads onto the summit plateau near the memorial to Charles Gough, who died on the ridge in 1805 and whose dog stayed by him for three months.
Swirral Edge is shorter and less continuous, but its top section is steeper, and in descent the first moves off the plateau are the hardest of the day. We suggest it as the way down only in dry conditions; when the rock is icy, a longer walk off the summit by the Wythburn path or over Raise to Sticks Pass is the sensible choice.
When the season turns
From November to April both mountains are winter mountains, and Striding Edge in particular becomes a serious undertaking. Snow banks out the path below the crest, the Chimney turns into an ice step, and the plateau edge above Red Tarn builds a cornice that has collapsed under walkers more than once. In these conditions an ice axe and crampons, and the practice to use them, are not optional. A daily assessment of ground conditions on Helvellyn is published through the winter months by the national park’s fell-top team, and it is worth reading the night before rather than guessing from the valley.
The essentials for either mountain in any season come down to a short list:
- A paper map and a compass, and the willingness to use them on the summit rather than at the car.
- Enough daylight: both classic rounds are six-hour days for a fit party, longer in winter.
- A forecast checked on the morning, since the summit of Scafell Pike is frequently in cloud when the valleys are clear.
- The nerve to turn back on Striding Edge or the boulder field if the wind makes standing difficult.
Which to do first
If you have one day, and the forecast is good, we would send you to Helvellyn: the eastern horseshoe is the more complete mountain experience, with the ridge, the tarn and the wide view east to the Pennines. Scafell Pike is the harder day on the legs and the less generous with scenery, but there is a satisfaction in standing on the roof of England that no other Lakeland summit gives. Done by the Corridor Route from Borrowdale, on a clear day, it is a walk that deserves every one of its visitors. Done in fog from Wasdale, in trainers, it is the reason the mountain rescue team stays busy. The mountain is the same; the difference is entirely in the preparation.
