Reading a Mountain Forecast, and Knowing When the Hill Says No

British hills are not high, and that is precisely the problem. A summit of 900 metres sits inside the weather rather than above it, on an island in the path of every Atlantic depression, and the gap between the valley forecast and what happens on the ridge is wider than almost anywhere else in Europe. Learning to read a proper mountain forecast, and then acting on it, is the single most useful skill we can offer anyone who walks in the Lake District, Snowdonia or the Highlands. It costs nothing and it is the one that prevents most of the incidents that end up in the rescue statistics.

Why the valley forecast is not enough

A general forecast describes conditions at the height where people live. Temperature falls by roughly one degree for every 100 metres of ascent in dry air, a little less in cloud, so a summit at 1,000 metres can be eight or nine degrees colder than the car park before wind is taken into account. Wind speed increases with height and accelerates over cols and ridges, and a pleasant 20 mph in the glen is routinely 50 mph on the plateau. Cloud base is the third variable, and it is the one the valley forecast rarely mentions at all: if it sits at 600 metres, every summit in the Lake District is in it.

For this reason, a dedicated mountain forecast is the only forecast we use for planning. Britain is well served: there are area-specific mountain forecasts for the Highlands, the Cairngorms, the Lake District, Snowdonia, the Peak District, the Brecon Beacons and the Yorkshire Dales, issued daily and written by forecasters who understand what the numbers mean for someone on foot.

The parts of the forecast that matter

A mountain forecast is a short document and every line earns its place. We read it in a fixed order, starting with the headline and moving to the detail.

  • Wind at summit level, given as an average and as gusts. Above 40 mph walking becomes tiring and balance on narrow ground is affected; above 50 mph most people are knocked off their feet by gusts; above 60 mph ridges and edges should be left alone.
  • The effect of wind on you. Some forecasts translate the numbers into plain language, and “walking difficult, occasionally impossible” is a sentence to take at face value.
  • Cloud base, and the chance of cloud-free summits, often expressed as a percentage. A 20 percent chance is a navigation day.
  • Precipitation type and timing, including whether rain is turning to snow at height and at what hour a front arrives.
  • Temperature at the summit and the freezing level, which decides whether the ground will be verglas-covered rock, soft snow or hard neve.
  • Visibility, in metres, separately from cloud. Fog on a plateau with a high cloud base is a different problem from cloud on a ridge.

Two things to note. First, forecasts are issued for a whole area, and the local terrain edits them: a north-facing corrie holds its own weather. Second, the outlook for the following days is the least reliable part, so a five-day plan should be re-read every evening.

Wind chill, wet cold and the numbers behind them

The temperature on the forecast is the air temperature, and it is not the one your body feels. Wind strips heat from exposed skin and damp clothing, and the combination of two degrees above freezing, rain and a 40 mph wind produces an effective temperature well below zero. This is the recipe for hypothermia in Britain, and it occurs far more often in wet autumn conditions than in dry winter cold. Most people who get into trouble on our hills do so at temperatures above freezing.

The practical response is layering and a policy of adding a layer before you feel cold rather than after. A hooded shell, a warm hat and spare gloves in a dry bag are the minimum in any month. A group should stop and eat before the shivering starts, because once it does, the decision-making quality of the coldest person is already impaired.

Reading the sky on the day

The forecast is a starting position, and the sky updates it. A high sheet of cirrus thickening from the west during the morning is the classic warning of a warm front, with rain typically six to twelve hours behind it. A sudden drop in temperature with a wind shift and a lifting cloud base is a cold front passing, usually followed by clearer, gustier conditions. Lenticular clouds over summits mean strong winds aloft, whatever the valley is doing. Cloud forming on the tops in the early afternoon on a warm day is normal convection and usually harmless; a dark anvil building rapidly to the south-west is not.

We keep a simple log on longer days: time, height, what the wind is doing, what the cloud is doing. It sounds pedantic. It is what lets you notice that the front has arrived two hours early, which is the fact that matters.

The decision to turn back

Every incident report we have read follows the same shape. The forecast was marginal, the party set off anyway with the reasonable intention of “seeing how it goes”, and then never found a moment that felt like the right one to stop. Turning back is a skill, and like taking a bearing it has to be practised before the day it is needed.

The method that works for us is to decide in the valley, in writing, what would make us turn round: a wind speed, a time at a named point, a cloud base, a river level. These are conditions, not feelings. On the hill, when one of them is met, the decision has already been made and all that remains is to carry it out. It removes the argument, and it removes the pressure of the person who has driven five hours for this summit. Escape routes should be identified on the map before the walk, with a note of which ones are unsafe in high wind or when streams are in spate. A line off a ridge that requires crossing a swollen beck is not an escape route.

Turning back is not failure

The summit will still be there next month. The people who spend their lives on British hills are, almost without exception, the ones with the longest list of days they abandoned. An out-and-back to a col in a gale, with a brew in the lee of a boulder, is a perfectly good day and often a more memorable one than the summit in mist would have been. Read the forecast, write down the limits, and let the hill say no when it needs to. It says yes often enough.